Manga Endoscopic vs Gastric Sleeve Surgery: A Comparative Analysis
What is the Manga Endoscópica procedure?
Manga Endoscópica, also known as Endoscopic Sleeve Gastroplasty (ESG), is a minimally invasive weight loss procedure where an endoscope is used to sew stitches in the stomach, creating a tube-like shape. The stomach’s capacity is reduced by up to 70%, resulting in reduced food intake, weight loss, and improved health outcomes. This procedure is ideal for those with a BMI between 30 and 39.9 and is not a suitable option for those with a BMI over 40.
What is the Manga Gástrica procedure?
Manga Gástrica, also known as gastric sleeve surgery, is a weight loss procedure that involves the removal of a large section of the stomach, leaving it roughly the size and shape of a banana. By reducing the size of the stomach, the amount of food intake needed to feel full is reduced, resulting in effective weight loss. This procedure is suitable for individuals with a BMI over 40 or those with a BMI over 35 who have associated health problems like diabetes, hypertension, sleep apnea, or high cholesterol.
Which procedure is better for weight loss?
Both Manga Endoscópica and Manga Gástrica are effective weight loss procedures that can help obese patients achieve sustainable long-term weight loss. The best option for you will depend on your age, weight, health, and personal goals. The Manga Endoscópica procedure is less invasive and has fewer side effects than Manga Gástrica. Also, it does not involve sutures or the removal of a stomach portion. As a result, the recovery period is faster, and the risk of complications is relatively low.
On the other hand, Manga Gástrica is a more invasive procedure, but it yields more significant and faster weight loss results. This procedure is ideal for those with a BMI over 40 or those with a BMI over 35 who have obesity-related health issues.
In summary, the Manga Endoscópica is a better option for those who are less obese and have a BMI between 30-39.9, while the Manga Gástrica is ideal for those who have a BMI of more than 40 or those whose BMI is over 35 and have accompanying health issues.
Understanding Manga Endoscopica
If you are considering a medical procedure to jump-start your weight loss journey, then there are two popular options: manga gástrica and manga endoscopica. While both of these bariatric procedures share some similarities, they work differently.
In this article, we are going to look at how manga endoscopica works, and what makes it stand out from the manga gástrica.
What is Manga Endoscopica?
Manga endoscopica, or endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty, is a type of minimally invasive weight loss procedure that involves shrinking the size of the stomach using an endoscope.
During the procedure, the surgeon inserts a flexible tube with a camera and suturing device into the stomach through the mouth. The camera allows the surgeon to visualize the stomach and determine where to stitch, while the suturing device is used to make several stitches that help to reduce the size of the stomach.
Essentially, the goal of this procedure is to turn the stomach into a narrow tube-like structure, which helps limit the amount of food you can eat and the time it takes for the food to leave the stomach.
The procedure takes anywhere from 60-90 minutes to complete, and you can leave the hospital on the same day.
The Manga Endoscopica Procedure
Prior to the procedure, the surgeon will order some tests to determine your eligibility. These can include blood tests, abdominal ultrasound, and endoscopy to rule out any underlying health conditions.
The procedure is done under general anesthesia, and you will not feel any pain. You will be asked to lie on your back, and the surgeon will insert the endoscope through your mouth and down your throat into your stomach.
Once the camera is in place, the surgeon will start making small stitches across the stomach wall, which will reduce the size of the stomach and change its shape. The number of stitches depends on the size of your stomach, and the surgeon will monitor the procedure progress through the camera.
After the procedure, you will be monitored for a few hours to make sure there are no complications. If everything goes well, you will be discharged and can resume your normal activities in a few days.
Benefits of Manga Endoscopica
The primary advantage of manga endoscopica over manga gástrica is that it is a minimally invasive procedure that does not involve any incisions. This reduces the risk of complications and speeds up the recovery time.
Other benefits include:
- It is an outpatient procedure, and you can go home the same day
- No permanent changes are made to your digestive system
- The procedure is reversible
- It is effective in promoting weight loss, improving metabolic health, and reducing the risk of chronic diseases
- It can be performed on patients with a BMI of 30 or higher
In Conclusion
Manga endoscopica is a relatively new weight loss procedure that offers a safe and effective way to shed excess weight without the need for surgery. If you are interested in pursuing this procedure, talk to your doctor to determine if you are eligible.
Remember to follow a strict diet and exercise regimen after the procedure to maximize your chances of success.
How does Manga Gástrica work?
Manga Gástrica, also known as gastric sleeve surgery, is a weight loss surgery that involves removing a portion of the stomach, leaving a sleeve-shaped portion that is about the size of a banana. This procedure reduces the stomach’s size by around 80%, which means that you will feel full quickly and will eat smaller portions. As a result, the body will take in fewer calories, leading to a caloric deficit that can help patients lose weight.
The procedure is usually performed laparoscopically under general anesthesia, which means that the surgeon will make several small incisions in the abdomen and insert a laparoscope, a thin camera that allows the surgeon to see inside the abdomen. The surgeon will also use small surgical instruments to remove a portion of the stomach and shape it into a sleeve. The procedure usually takes between one and two hours, and most patients stay in the hospital for one or two days after surgery.
Manga Gástrica has become increasingly popular among people who struggle with obesity and have not been able to lose weight through diet and exercise. This procedure is considered one of the most effective ways to achieve significant and sustained weight loss, as it has been shown to lead to an average weight loss of around 60-70% of excess weight within the first two years after surgery.
While the main goal of the procedure is to aid in weight loss, it also has other potential benefits, such as improving blood sugar levels, reducing the risk of heart disease, and lowering blood pressure. In addition, patients who undergo Manga Gástrica often report an improvement in their overall quality of life, including increased energy levels, improved sleep, and a decrease in the symptoms of depression and anxiety.
However, it’s important to note that Manga Gástrica is not a magic solution for weight loss, and it requires significant lifestyle changes, including a healthy diet and regular exercise, to be effective in the long term. It also comes with some risks and potential complications, such as infection, bleeding, and blood clots, and patients should discuss these risks with their doctor before undergoing the procedure.
In conclusion, Manga Gástrica is a weight loss surgery that involves removing a portion of the stomach, leaving a sleeve-shaped portion that reduces the stomach’s size by around 80%. This procedure has become increasingly popular among people struggling with obesity and has been shown to be one of the most effective ways to achieve significant and sustained weight loss. However, it also requires significant lifestyle changes and comes with some risks and potential complications that patients should discuss with their doctor before undergoing the procedure.
Comparing the Amount of Weight Loss
Manga Endoscópica and Manga Gástrica are both effective procedures for weight loss. However, it is important to understand how much weight loss can be expected from each procedure to make an informed decision.
Manga Endoscópica involves placing a small inflatable balloon in the stomach, which is then filled with saline solution. This balloon takes up space in the stomach, creating a feeling of fullness, and reducing food intake. According to studies, patients who have undergone this procedure have lost an average of 15-20% of their body weight within six months to two years.
On the other hand, Manga Gástrica involves surgically reducing the size of the stomach. This procedure restricts the amount of food that can be consumed, resulting in weight loss. According to studies, patients who have undergone this procedure have lost an average of 25-30% of their body weight within two years.
It is important to note, however, that the amount of weight loss can vary from person to person, and can also depend on several factors such as age, overall health, and individual metabolic rates. It is best to consult with a healthcare provider to determine which procedure is best suited for one’s individual needs.
Long-Term Outcomes
While both procedures have shown promising results in the short-term, the long-term outcomes are still being studied. It is important to consider the potential risks and benefits of each procedure before making a decision.
Some potential long-term risks of Manga Endoscópica include deflation of the balloon, which can lead to discomfort, and a small risk of obstruction if the balloon moves. Additionally, there is limited long-term data on the effectiveness of the procedure beyond two years.
Similarly, some potential long-term risks of Manga Gástrica include staple line leaks, gastrointestinal bleeding, and malabsorption of nutrients. While the procedure has shown long-term effectiveness in weight loss, it is important to follow a strict, long-term diet and exercise plan to maintain weight loss and prevent potential complications.
Ultimately, the decision to undergo either procedure should be made with careful consideration of individual goals, potential risks, and long-term outcomes. It is best to consult with a healthcare provider to discuss which procedure may be best suited for one’s individual needs.
What are the risks of each procedure?
Choosing between Manga Endoscópica and Manga Gástrica procedures is a critical decision that patients must make with their doctors. However, just like any vital surgery, both procedures carry certain risks that patients should know before signing on the dotted line.
Risks of Manga Endoscópica
Manga Endoscópica is a less invasive procedure, which means that the risks are relatively minimal. The procedure involves inserting an endoscopic tube through the mouth into the stomach to reduce its size. Although it is less invasive, there are some risks such as:
- Bleeding: While the process doesn’t include incisions or cuts, the entry into the stomach can lead to bleeding. Bleeding may be trivial in most cases, but it can be challenging to control in rare situations.
- Perforation: In rare cases, the endoscopic tube can pierce through the wall of the stomach, which is why the process should be performed by experienced professionals. If this occurs, the patient may need immediate surgery.
- Infection: Although it is very uncommon, endoscopy procedures may introduce bacteria into the body, causing infection. Impaired immune systems and long procedures increase a patient’s risk of developing an infection. Patients should monitor and report any symptoms of infection to their doctor in such cases.
- Pain and discomfort: Patients may encounter moderate pain and uncomfortable feelings, primarily when the endoscopic tube is inserted through the throat and into the stomach. Pain may last for some hours after the procedure, but patients can take painkillers to relieve this.
- Serious complications: Although it is uncommon, serious adverse effects, such as severe bleeding, infection, and punctured organs, can occur during the procedure.
Risks of Manga Gástrica
Manga Gástrica is an invasive surgery that offers significant weight loss but comes with higher risks than Manga Endoscópica. Possible risks of Manga Gástrica includes:
- Bleeding: As with other surgery, patients may encounter bleeding as a result of Manga Gástrica. The potential for hemorrhage is higher in this procedure because of the alteration on the stomach, a vital organ. Patients should contact their doctor immediately if they experience severe bleeding.
- Infection: Patients that undergo surgery, especially those with other medical conditions, are at risk of infection. Doctors prescribe antibiotics to prevent the onset of infections, but it’s crucial to notify the doctor if signs of infection develop after surgery.
- Deep vein thrombosis: Patients undergoing Manga Gástrica may have an increased risk of developing blood clots. They are encouraged to move around and exercise to increase blood flow and prevent clots from forming in the vein.
- Pulmonary embolism: While Deep vein thrombosis is a clot in the leg veins, the clot can break away and move to the lungs, causing pulmonary embolism. Signs such as shortness of breath, chest pains, and coughing blood should be alerted to the surgeon immediately.
- Leakage: During the procedure, part of the stomach is removed, and the remaining part is stapled and sealed. Leakage may occur in some patients, which is life-threatening if ignored. However, if the leak is detected early, patients may require a revision surgery to seal the part of the stomach again.
In conclusion, patients must work with their doctors to learn the potential risks and benefits of Manga Endoscópica and Manga Gástrica. This knowledge helps those considering either procedure to make informed decisions and prepare for any potential post-surgical complications.
Manga Endoscópica vs. Manga Gástrica
Manga Endoscópica and Manga Gástrica are two weight loss procedures that have gained popularity in recent years. Both procedures offer a less invasive approach to weight loss than traditional bariatric surgeries, but they differ in terms of how they work and who they are suitable for.
Manga Endoscópica, also known as Endoscopic Sleeve Gastroplasty (ESG), involves reducing the size of the stomach using an endoscope. This procedure is done by making small incisions in the abdominal area and inserting the endoscope with a camera and a set of tools to remove a portion of the stomach and shape it into a tube-like structure. This results in a smaller stomach capacity, making the person feel fuller faster and eat less.
Manga Gástrica, also known as Sleeve Gastrectomy, is a surgical procedure that involves permanently removing a significant portion of the stomach, leaving behind a small, banana-shaped pouch that can hold much less food. Unlike Manga Endoscópica, Sleeve Gastrectomy is a permanent surgical procedure that uses stapling or suturing to create the smaller stomach pouch.
Both procedures are effective in promoting weight loss, with studies showing an average weight loss of 15-20% of excess body weight in the first year after the procedure. But which procedure is right for you?
Manga Endoscópica vs. Manga Gástrica: Pros and Cons
The decision to undergo a Manga Endoscópica or Manga Gástrica procedure will depend on a variety of factors, including your individual weight loss goals, your health status, and your ability to undergo either procedure. Here are some pros and cons of each procedure:
Manga Endoscópica Pros:
- Less invasive than traditional bariatric surgeries
- No need for surgical incisions
- Shorter recovery time, usually one to two days
- No need for general anesthesia in some cases
- Lower risk of complications than Manga Gástrica
Manga Endoscópica Cons:
- May not be suitable for individuals with a larger stomach size or severe obesity
- Weight loss results may not be as long-lasting as Manga Gástrica
- May require multiple procedures
- Insurance coverage may vary
Manga Gástrica Pros:
- More effective in promoting long-term weight loss than Manga Endoscópica
- Permanent change to stomach size and structure
- May improve or resolve obesity-related health conditions
- No need for multiple procedures
- Insurance coverage may be more widely available
Manga Gástrica Cons:
- Invasive surgical procedure with a longer recovery time
- Requires general anesthesia
- Higher risk of complications than Manga Endoscópica
- May not be suitable for individuals with certain health conditions or previous surgeries
Which Procedure Is Right for Me?
Ultimately, the decision to undergo a Manga Endoscópica or Manga Gástrica procedure should be made after consultation with a qualified medical professional, who can help determine the best course of action based on your individual health and weight loss goals. It’s important to carefully consider the pros and cons of each procedure, as well as any potential risks or complications, before making a decision.
In general, Manga Endoscópica may be a good option for individuals with a BMI between 30 and 40 who have not had success with diet and exercise alone, or who are not eligible for traditional bariatric surgery due to health conditions or other factors. Manga Gástrica, on the other hand, may be more suitable for individuals with a BMI over 40 or who have obesity-related health conditions that would benefit from significant weight loss.
Ultimately, the decision to undergo either procedure should be based on your individual health needs and weight loss goals, as well as the advice and guidance of a qualified medical professional